The last superstition edward feser, the mustard seed bookshop. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Why science hasnt disproved free will, by alfred mele, and he claims that mele demonstrates that scientific evidence comes nowhere close to undermining free will, and that the reasoning leading some scientists to claim otherwise is amazingly sloppy. Click on the members below to view samples of their work. Edward fesers book is a timely wakeup call to the many people who have been seduced by the amateurish attempts at philosophy of religion found in the. Feser concludes his essay by remarking that in this one brief passage, then, rothbard commits a host of fallacies and fails even to acknowledge, such less answer, a number of obvious objections that might be raised against his argument. A refutation of the new atheism, and edward feser is associate professor of philosophy at pasadena city college.
Jun 14, 2016 even worse, despite fesers impressive efforts, he fails to prove the necessity, truth, or usefulness of aristotelian moral reasoning, and aristotles philosophyat least as presented in the last superstitionstill appears, if not utterly bankrupt, unsatisfying and problematic. A refutation of the new atheism, that is not entirely the case. The most prominent of the new atheists is richard dawkins. Dec 10, 2010 a common saying in philosophy is that you can read a book and enjoy it very much, even if you agree with not a word of it. In the preface to the book, feser identifies two widespread abnormalities in western culture, sexual libertinism and contempt for religion, which are the result of the modern scientific worldview which has become dominant over the past 400 years. These people share a similar superstitious outlook on life as the bible. A refutation of the new atheism chapter 2 greeks bearing gifts all throughout the preface and the first chapter feser made numerous extremely bold claims that he promises to back up in the later chapters. Feser is being too modest when he describes his work as a refutation for it is much more than that. A refutation of the new atheism by feser, edward isbn. I am pleased to announce that my book the last superstition. Jan 19, 2015 thus, it restores that awareness of philosophic immediacy that wilhelmsen, to whom feser refers, rightly thought to be lost when the schools abandoned scholastic philosophy for what turns out to be mostly a mess of pottage. Quite the contrary, feser suggests, the existence of god can be proved by rationally compelling arguments. In various previous posts ive looked at aspects of fesers book in some detail. But as edward feser shows in the last superstition, there is not, and never has.
Pawleys island, south carolina, seemed an idyllic place, until an unsolved murder the grisly stabbing of teenager tara mitchell and the disappearance of her two. In the closing pages of this book, edward feser sums up his thesis, arguing. I read last year a very good work on the last days and crucifixion of jesus by a. This alone may tell you whether or not this book is for you or not it introduces fesers polemic style, and it.
Edward feser is associate professor of philosophy at pasadena city college. Augustines press, 2010 available on amazon us and amazon canada feser has the rare and enviable gift of making philosophical argument. There has instead been a conflict between two entirely philosophical conceptions of the natural order. Feser shows that aquinass philosophy is still a live option for thinkers today. This is a popularization of contemporary philosophy, a piece of cultural criticism, a history of western thought and a response to the new atheists. A refutation of the new atheism, aquinas, scholastic meta physics, by man shall his blood be shed, and many other books and articles. Feser has published a book on atheism, the last superstitiongreat title.
In the case of edward feser s the last superstition. Feser on rothbard as a philosopher mises institute. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. But as edward feser shows in the last superstition, there is not, and never has been, any war between science and religion at all. A superstition says that if a team has scored 111 runs, all players but the batsman should raise one leg above the ground. On 25 july, members of the sydney traditionalist forum attended a special lecture at the university of notre dame, sydney, with american academic dr. In order to combat it, he turns to st thomas aquinas and the aristotelian tradition and he faults modern philosophy of leaving itself open to the last superstition by rejecting that tradition.
A refutation of the new atheism that dawkins has it all wrong. This worldview itself is the result of a philosophical error which is the subject of feser s book. Edward feser is the author of the last superstition. But as edward feser argues inthe last superstition, in fact there is not, and never has been, any war between science and religion at all. The central contention of the new atheism of richard dawkins, daniel dennett, sam harris, and christopher hitchens is that there has for several centuries been a. Feser does yeomans work in offering a clear and concise presentation of what can be very difficult to understand for the beginner. Dec 10, 2010 the last superstition by edward feser, 9781587314520, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Ive read the first chapter and the preface and i have to say that the book seems like an interesting read. Almost all academics, unless libertarians themselves, associate libertarianism with one person. The last superstition a refutation of the new atheism by edward feser claims to be an attempt to show that atheism is essentially irrational and that belief in. There has instead been a the central contention of the new atheism of richard dawkins, daniel dennett, sam harris, and christopher hitchens is that the centuriesold war between science and religion is now over and that religion has lost. A refutation of the new atheism kindle edition by feser, edward. The focus of the lecture, the last superstition, was to offer a proof of the existence of a divine being through the use of logic and philosophy. But as edward feser argues inthe last superstition, in fact there is not, and never has.
Edward feser is associate professor of philosophy at pasadena city college in pasadena, california. T he spate of bad books on philosophy and religion by. In the case of edward fesers the last superstition. The myth was started by umpire david shepherd, who also sometimes hopped or jumped. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the last superstition. The publishers blurb tells us that this book has been widely hailed as the strongest argument ever made against the new atheists. South africa and australia played a match on november 11, 2011. Feser first tackles the work of neurobiologist benjamin libet. Oct 30, 2014 well the book, called the last superstition. The validity of superstitions is based on belief in the power of magic and witchcraft and in such invisible forces as spirits and demons.
I enjoyed all of the book, but i strongly disagreed with the last quarter of the book. A refutation of the new atheism makes a philosophical argument for the classical aristotelianthomistic worldview over and. A refutation of the new atheism by edward feser st. His most recent books include aquinas and the last superstition. A concise, accessible, and compelling introduction to aquinass thought. The book gets emotional and insulting every now and then but as feser explains in the beginning, it is a reaction to even more emotional and insulting books of. Buy a cheap copy of superstition book by karen robards. List of books and articles about superstition online. Edward feser, associate professor of philosophy at pasadena city college in pasadena, california, seeks to free us from such a tyranny in his remarkable book the last superstition. Not understanding nothing by edward feser articles first. A refutation of the new atheism, written by a philosopher named edward feser, arrived a few days ago. The last superstition by edward feser is an or recheck it out from the library which is what i did.
Become a fan of first things on facebook, subscribe to first things via rss, and follow first things on twitter. Edward feser just released a new book, titled five proofs of the existence of god ignatius press, 2017. A refutation of the new atheism will be published this october by st. Feser from his sharply reasoned posts here at strange notions, or from his popular blog, which mainly focuses on the philosophy of religion. If you dont have much experience with philosophy andor metaphysics, the process of contemplating ideas that are foreign to you can take time to get used to. A contemporary introduction, is perhaps the one closest to a pure philosophy. Celebrating the last freedom ot his creature and of papal. Feser 2006 i hope that the foregoing analysis has shown this claim to be ungrounded, and that the.
A common saying in philosophy is that you can read a book and enjoy it very much, even if you agree with not a word of it. I should also say to those of you who are not initiated in philosophy, this book can. In that case, log out, choose your books after clicking the link and only register again if you want to pay. A refutation of the new atheism sets the tone for the entire work, as it asserts in bold letters across the cover that atheism is the ultimate superstition. God is not a hypothesis, to be replaced if a more satisfactory theory comes up. A refutation of the new atheism makes a philosophical argument for the classical aristotelianthomistic worldview over and against the materialist assumptions and scientistic prejudices of contemporary atheists such as richard dawkins, of whom he is particularly critical. Edward feser lecture, the last superstition at the. Nov 19, 2011 the title of edward fesers book the last superstition. There has instead been a conflict between two entirely philosophical worldviews. Professor edward feser argues in his brilliant new book the last superstition.
170 449 1391 270 108 474 976 1242 385 662 1151 1197 784 1424 181 661 1241 309 145 489 824 977 308 1125 1267 785 1612 238 755 175 594 811 691 556 2 541 1173 1089 1423 221